Monthly Archives: September 2013


A grim but fascinating book

I recently read Five Days at Memorial: Life and Death in a Storm-Ravaged Hospital by Sheri Fink.  It reconstructs the horrible conditions faced by the staff of a hospital that became an island during Hurricane Katrina. They had no power and no running water, yet still had to care for 180 patients, many of them critically and/or terminally ill.  Temperatures inside reached 110 degrees. What actually happened there is still in dispute–but a doctor and two nurses were arrested for murder of 20 people.  The grand jury failed to indict them.  Was it murder, mercy killing, or administration of comfort care?

Reviews of “The Language of Flowers”

Author Vanessa Diffenbaugh

September 23, 2013

Host: Maureen

Reviews of “Room”

Room by Emma Donaghue

August 26, 2013

Host: Jackie

Reviews of Books Before August 2013

130722Flight Behavior

130624Italian Shoes

130527Armageddon in Retrospect

130422Where River Turns to Sk

130325The Dovekeepers

130225Crossing to Safety

130128End of Your Life BC

Reading Between the Wines Rules

At our August meeting, we discussed how things are going in general and what, if any, changes we would like to make.  Here are the thoughts I captured.  Feel free to use this as a basis for further discussion.

*We will continue to meet on the fourth Monday of the month, from 3:00 to 5:00 p.m.  No December meetings.

*We will continue to keep the final observations pages and rating system for the books we have read.

*We will continue to allow each member to speak without interruption.  However, there is some frustration that it inhibits discussion. We decided that when a member is speaking, she has the option to open the floor to discussion on a particular subject.  She can close down the discussion when she feels the topic has been sufficiently explored.  For example, in speaking about Room, Mary said she didn’t understand Ma’s suicide attempt and she hoped other members could shed some light on it.  In the future, Mary could ask for direct input on the subject.

*We decided to set a maximum membership at ten.  Membership is by invitation only.  Current members should consult the group before asking someone to join.

*Two people–Peggi Towne and Phyllis Gabler–have been invited to join us. Each has shown interest, but each has conflicts that have prevented them from participating.  Through the use of this blog, they can follow along as “correspondent members” until such time as it is possible for them to join us in person.

Submitted by Jackie

Jackie’s Favorites

I read about 50% fiction and 50% nonfiction.

I do love mysteries, especially the one’s called “cozies.”  You know, body in the library and everyone drinking tea and saying, “Oh, my! Poor chap.”

My current favorites include (read them in chronological order, unless otherwise indicated):

Maisie Dobbs series by Jacqueline Winspear, set in post WWI England

Flavia de Luce series by Alan Bradley, also set in England with a funny young girl detective.

Anything by Anthony Berkeley, who wrote in the 1920s-19302.  Devilishly clever.  Not necessary to read in order.

The Louise Penny series.  Love, love, love it.

I also love historical fiction.  I recommend the first two books of Hilary Mantel’s trilogy of the life of Thomas Cromwell.  They are: Wolf’s Hall  and Bring Up the Bodies.

I heartily recommend Ken Follett’s books set in 12th century England.  The Pillars of the Earth and World Without End.

I just realized every book I names above is set in England.  Hmmmm. I must be an Anglophile.

MY ALLTIME FAVORITE nonfiction book is The Fourth Turning by Strauss and Howe.  I could practically pay someone to read and discuss it with me.

Recommendations:

 

Lamb: The Gospel According to Biff, Christ’s Childhood Pal by Christopher Moore

 

A Prayer for Owen Meany by John Irving

 

A Dog Walks into  Nursing Home by Sue Halpern

 

The “Gordianus the Finder” mystery series by Steven Saylor.  The first book in the series is Roman Blood.

Maureen’s Favorites

Maureen’s favorites:

  • Barbara Kingsolver is one of my favorite authors. Her Poisonwood Bible is one of my all-time favorite books.  It took me a while to get into The Lacuna, but when I reached the end I was soooo glad I got all the way through it.  I haven’t read her latest yet, but it’s on my list of books to read.
  • Detective stories:  I like the same kinds of books that Catherine described, and I have read Fred Vargas and Louise Penney from her list.  I like them a lot and I’ll keep moving through their books, and then I’ll go on to her other mystery authors. 
  • Patrick O’Brien wrote 20 novels referred to as the Aubrey-Maturin Series, and I’ve read them all.  Captain Jack Aubrey and Steven Maturin, a naturalist and ship’s doctor, sail all over the world for the British Navy starting in 1805.  The books should be read in order, starting with Master and Commander.

Russell Crowe played Aubrey in a movie of the same name, which I liked very much although the story is actually a combination of later books and not the same as the first book.  I like the historical context and details and the sea-going adventures.

  • I like to read classics, and recently I’ve been going back to Victorian novels.  I’ve read all of Jane Austen and most of Charles Dickens, as well as Emily and Charlotte Bronte.  Another writer of that time that I recently “discovered” is Elizabeth Gaskell.  By the way, a very interesting book about certain writers of that period is Parallel Lives by Phyllis Rose.  It gives portraits of 5 Victorian couples, people who were literary leaders of the time.  Charles Dickens and George Elliot are among the people profiled within their relationships. 
  • I have enjoyed Colleen McCullough’s series on ancient Rome, starting with The First Man in Rome, and also Jean Auel’s prehistory series which starts with Clan of the Cave Bear.  I don’t consider these exceptional literary works, but both authors have done extensive research and they write intelligently. I like them especially for the details about daily life in each historical context. 
  • Other books I recommend: 
  • The Cairo Trilogy by Naguib Mahfouz  (3 books)
  • My Reading Life  by Pat Conroy, nonfiction
  • Shadow of the Wind  by Carlos Ruiz Zafon
  • Cutting for Stone by Abraham Verghese
  • Devil in the White City by Erik Larson, nonfiction
  • Parallel Lives by Phyllis Rose, nonfiction
  • Suite Francaise by Irene Nemirovsky
  • Bel Canto by Ann Patchett

Catherine’s Favorites

Here is the list of authors that I really enjoy.  I go for the mystery with a great atmospheric storyline and unique characters.

 

Louise Penny, Chief Inspector Gamache series of mysteries which take place in a small Quebec town.

 

Martin Walker, Chief of Police Bruno which takes place in a small French village in the Dordogne region.

 

Andrea Camilleri, Inspector Montalbano which takes place in Sicily.

 

Fred Vargas, Commissaire Adamsberg, a wonderfully intuitive French policeman.

 

All have great storylines and they get into the history and other interesting aspects of the region where the stories take place, such as the truffle trade and the cave paintings of the Dordogne valley.  Reading these authors is like taking a vacation and moving into the various towns for a month, meeting the locals, smelling the smells and tasting the food and wine.  They all build on the prior book somewhat so I like to start at the beginning of a series.  There are 5 to 9 books from each author in a series and I watch with anticipation for new releases.

 

Catherine

Schedule

Date Host Book Author Type Rating
January 28 Jackie The End of Your Life Book Club Will Schwalbe nonfiction 4.4
February 25 Maureen Crossing to Safety Wallace Stegner fiction 3.2
March 25 Linda The Dovekeepers Alice Hoffman fiction 3
April 22 Mary Where River Turns to Sky Gregg Kleiner fiction 4
May 27 Ginney Armageddon in Retrospect Kurt Vonnegut short stories 2.8
June 24 Catherine Italian Shoes Henning Mankell Fiction 3.7
July 22 Victoria Flight Behavior Barbara Kingsolver Fiction
August 26 Jackie Room: A Novel Emma Donoghue Fiction
September 23 Maureen The Language of Flowers Vanessa Diffenbaugh Fiction
October 28 Linda Private Life Jane Smiley Fiction
November 25 Mary
January 27, 2014 Ginney
February 23, 2014 Catherine
March 24, 2014 Victoria